College Board Connection Commentary
The College Board's mission is to connect students to college success and opportunity. We are a not-for-profit membership organization committed to excellence and equity in education.
. . Sign up to receive Connection
COLLEGEBOARD.COM New England Middle States Southwest South Midwest West International
Connection Home
Latest News
Advocacy
Programs and Services
Membership Matters
Commentary
Events and Workshops
2008
   
  Aug/Sept
  Jun
May
Apr
Mar
Feb
Jan

2007

Nov

Commentary

Gene Budig
Gene Budig



Academic Values and
Big Time Athletics,
a Growing Dilemma



By Gene Budig


Many of my friends are college and university presidents, past and present, and our conversations almost always delve into the state of athletics. These individuals are, without question, enlightened men and women who admit that the so-called “arms race” is not subsiding, not by a long shot.

In 2008 there is a growing and insatiable appetite for college athletics among students, alumni, trustees and the general public. Fiscal restraint is rare. College athletics has become a big, big business, offering real competition to major professional sports: football, basketball, baseball and NASCAR.

College football coaches often make 10 times as much as well-established professors. It would seem that some schools are focused more on “parties and spectacle” than on teaching
and learning.

The average pay for major college football coaches surpasses
$1 million a year, and the same is true for frontline college basketball coaches. Assistant coaches in both men’s sports are beneficiaries of spiraling salaries, too.

pull_quote_line

College football coaches often make 10 times as much as well-established professors.
It would seem that some schools are focused more on “parties and spectacle” than
on teaching and learning.

pull_quote_line_bottom

With regard to faculty salaries, only some
fields like business,
engineering and computer science pay
in the range of $100,000
to $120,000 a year.
Instructors, who often
carry the heaviest
teaching loads for
undergraduate classes,
receive less
than $53,000.

Some representatives from the National Collegiate Athletic Association actually defend, with a straight face, the high pay of football and men’s basketball coaches, explaining that coaches, unlike the faculty, do not have tenure.

The head football coaches from Alabama, Iowa, Florida and Oklahoma receive more than $3 million a year and others are about to catch them.

Too few citizens realize that only a few major athletic programs actually make money, and the rest struggle to break even. Even with television income, growing ticket sales and prices, costly marketing and generous contributions from supporters, big-time athletics is a high-risk business. At last count, among the 119 schools with top Division 1 football teams, only 15 had athletic departments that made a profit. The others continue to envision
a profit.

Too many athletic departments rely on some form of university subsidy, a sore point with faculty and politicians, and such subsidies are often well disguised. A growing number of elected officials in Washington believe that athletic departments have more influence than they should and need to be reined in.

Members of the House Ways and Means Committee, believing athletic programs are in many instances undercutting institutional missions, are likely to call for hearings during the 2009 session. Any intrusion from Congress is certain to be discouraged by college presidents and their trustees who understand the depth of feelings of legions of people. Any real action seems unlikely at this time. 

What sobers many of my presidential friends is the possibility of a significant drop in the popularity of college sports. And some believe that will happen because athletic events are overexposed now that they are on so many network and cable outlets.

pull_quote_line

A growing number of elected officials in Washington believe that athletic departments have more influence than they should and need
to be reined in.

pull_quote_line_bottom

Myles Brand, the NCAA president who in recent times has led the successful charge for needed reform in academic standards
for athletes, has said, “Institutions hold mortgages on burgeoning facility expansion that represents on average
20 percent of intercollegiate
athletics spending.”

According to several prominent university heads, Dr. Brand will be pushed by his membership to devote even more attention to the bottom line or what the budget numbers portend. Clearly, it would a gut-wrenching exercise for many on and off the campus, but the clock is ticking.

One can assume mounting and loud criticism from certain students who will be paying increased tuition and fees. Growth in student costs has been disproportionate in recent years and there is no letup in sight.

Athletic programs are complex. They defy simplistic remedies. In truth, they are a combination of academics, societal values, business and sports, and they always stir heated emotions from many sides, from zealot fans to cerebral professors.

 

Gene A. Budig is the former president/chancellor of Illinois State University, West Virginia University, and the University of Kansas and past president of Major League Baseball’s American League. He is a distinguished professor at the College Board in New York and author of “Grasping the Ring.”

Email This StorySave to FavoritesPrint
Featured Article
» National Writing Project and Google Team Up for Students’ Writing
In Previous Issue
» Deborah Bial:
The Posse Foundation Creates Network
of Leaders
» Principal and Counselor Collaboration
»
» Academic Values and
Big Time Athletics,
a Growing Dilemma
Letters to the Editor
College Board Connection publishes thoughtful, appropriately written Letters to the Editor every issue when submitted. Such letters should be no more than
300 words in length. We reserve the right to edit for content and length. Please include a daytime phone number, and send to connection@collegeboard.org.
Membership
Stay Informed. Get Connected. Grow Progessionally

Interested in Becoming a Member?
Learn More

 
 Copyright © 2008 collegeboard.com, Inc.